The Other Side of Grace

Being loved and accepting grace, even while still broken, is a vital step for every person. Learn how modern neuroscience teaches us that emotions, identity, and healing don’t happen in isolation. Transformation is forged in the fire of relationship.

Often, the traditional understanding of grace emphasizes that we do not deserve to be forgiven, highlighting God’s incredible sacrifice that cost him so dearly. It focuses on our complete badness, recognizing that there is nothing good in us, our total inability to possess strength or talent, and a punitive God who was punishing us, as we deserve. While there is truth in much of this, we miss the “other side of the grace.”

God also wants us to experience His delight and enjoyment, even when we have sin, are selfish, have bad impulses, such as rage or lust, or are unkind. (“negative realities”). He wants us to experience ourselves as lovable, valued, capable, and desired in a relationship. Forgiveness of sins addresses our guilt. But delight and enjoyment helps alleviate our shame. We need both. Forgiveness restores us legally.

Delight restores us emotionally and relationally. And shame is often the deeper wound. When all we hear is “you are forgiven,” our faith can become transactional: “I mess up, God forgives me, I try harder.” But when we encounter God’s enjoyment of us in our sin, and “negative realities, we discover a more powerful motivator than fear or duty. We experience belonging, safety, love, worthiness, joy, and a peace that transcends understanding (Philippians 4:7). This is the other side of the grace.

From Bright Morning Star

Morning Notes in your inbox: a short devotional every weekday morning. Free, always. Subscribe.

Jesus modeled this other side of grace with the Woman at the Well. He only referred to her sinfulness, so she could realize, “he knew everything I ever did” (John 4:29), and yet was drawing closer to her. He never mentioned her sin for the rest of the time they were together. Rather, he demonstrated that he experienced her as lovable and enjoyed the relationship. He restored her relational status, which is evident in her interactions with the village.

Jesus illustrates this other side of grace beautifully in the Parable of the Prodigal Son. The father ran out to his son not merely to cancel his debt but to embrace him, clothe him in honor, and throw a feast to restore him relationally to himself, his family, and the community. It didn’t matter if he was repentant or not. Which, by the way, he wasn’t.

He rehearsed his 3-line manipulation just to get back into his father’s house. He misunderstood the father’s heart, thinking it was about performance and doing the right thing. His new relational understanding was that he could be loved and respected when he wasn’t “performing” well. He didn’t catch this until after the powerful relational experience with his father. He was loved in the midst of his disobedience and disgust for everything the father stood for (taking a job feeding “unclean” pigs would be considered abhorrent, the son dishonored himself, his father’s reputation in the community, and symbolically spat on his father’s Jewishness). This powerful relational experience sank in immediately because he left off the last line of his rehearsed apology – “I am no longer worthy to be called your son,” – earning his way back into his father’s good graces (performance).

Here is the “icing on the cake.” God’s grace through Jesus’ death and resurrection was not just about individual sin but a broader narrative of God’s covenantal justice, rescue, and renewal, rather than the traditional penal substitutionary lens of appeasing God’s wrath toward us as sinners who needed to be punished. For N. T. Wright (2016), justification is God declaring a person to be in the right, as part of the renewed covenant family, not performance. A family originally defined by the covenantal promises to Abraham, which is now fulfilled through Jesus in the new covenantal family of the church – the body of Christ and the family of God (the 2 most used metaphors of the church). Justification means you belong to God’s restored people, brought about through Jesus’ faithfulness and the cross – “while we were yet sinners.” Wright (2016, p. 384) states, “Justification is about being declared to be in the right—marked out, vindicated—as a member of God’s true covenant family.”

It is declared, not earned. You are automatically part of the family regardless! Wright (2016) points out that this means we are not only reconciled to God, but to one another. Reconciliation demonstrates that we are now a part of a family that is not based on our performing our way into it (like the Prodigal Son felt). It is defined by loving relationships (i.e., a covenantal relationship) that exist even in the presence of sin or “negative realities.” People will not withdraw from us when we mess up. We are God’s children and co-heirs with Christ. That doesn’t change when we are imperfect.

It is not enough to just know this intellectually!

We often hear, “All you need is God.” However, Scripture and neuroscience suggest a more nuanced perspective: God is sufficient in Himself, but by His design, we need one another. He created us to grow, heal, and thrive through relationships. If anyone had a close relationship with God, it was Adam. He walked with God in perfect communion. Yet God looked at him and said, “It is not good for the man to be alone.” Even in the presence of divine perfection, God declared something was missing—a relationship with another human.

Neuroscience confirms our brains are wired for connection. Emotions, identity, and healing don’t happen in isolation. They are forged in the fire of relationship, with faces, voices, and presence. God made your nervous system so that it requires others to regulate emotion, form identity, and even experience His love more deeply.

Knowing God loves you is not the same as experiencing His love through someone else’s smile, empathy, or kindness. I John 4:12 says: “No one has ever seen God; but if we love one another, God lives in us and his love is made complete in us.” God’s love is made complete, not alone on a mountaintop, but in relationship. Click here for a fun video that illustrates our need for relationships as we face life’s challenges.

Jesus didn’t disciple through downloads of information. He formed a group to experience love daily and understand how to share it with the world. More importantly, when he was overwhelmed with anxiety and sadness after the last supper, he did not go to the Father alone. He asked the disciples to join him. He needed their presence, their relationship. Arriving in the Garden, he asked Peter, James, and John to be even closer. He needed it so much that he went back twice and vulnerably asked for closeness again when they fell asleep.

Paul needed Titus when he was overwhelmed upon entering Macedonia (2 Corinthians 7:5-7). God was not enough. He was comforted by a human relationship (i.e., “God with skin”). The other significant part of this interaction is when Titus reminded him of past relationships with the Corinthian church and how they “longed for me, your deep sorrow, your ardent concern for me.” Then Paul said the most profound thing, “my joy was even greater.” Even a memory of past human relationships can comfort us in our “fears within” and when we are “downcast.”

You were never meant to “white-knuckle” your spiritual life alone, or just with God. You were made to receive His love through people. Real comfort or healing doesn’t happen as powerfully through God alone or new insights, willpower, or doing all the right things. It happens through safe relationships that love you even with the bad parts.

We need both an intimacy with God to feel his love, and we need the same with our present human relationships. We were designed to handle life’s challenges and to mature in our faith only by having both kinds of relationships. When we only have one side, life becomes more difficult, and our growth is not as powerful as it could be. This is why the major metaphors for the church are relational: God’s family and Christ’s body. Ephesians 4:16 tells us growth occurs when each person is doing their part in fostering intimate relationships with one another. Jesus designed the church to be more than just worshiping God or studying His Word. Click here for a paper that reflects Robert Bank’s revolutionary book, Paul’s idea of community: Spirit and culture in early house churches, and how we can implement these principles in the 21st century.

But there is more!

Neuroscience now confirms what Scripture has long declared. They discovered principles that are very contrary to our usual understanding that our brains change if we know the right thing to do (which Paul showed in Romans 7 doesn’t work) or through willpower (the weakest part of human beings, “The spirit is willing, but the flesh is weak” Matt. 26:41) or following the rules and commands of Scripture (“Such regulations have an appearance of wisdom, with their self-imposed will worship, their false humility … but they lack any value in restraining sensual indulgence” Col. 2:23).

God designed the other side of grace into the very fabric of our brains through a process called Memory Reconsolidation – “the brain’s innate mechanism for allowing current experiences to revise or ‘update’ existing contents of memory, changing both the neural encoding of the target memory and its expression into subjective experiences and behavior” (Vaz & Ecker, 2020, p. 2019). God designed our brains to give us a second chance with past or present painful relational experiences, full of shame. When we re-experience these shame-filled emotions (“I’m unlovable,” “I’m a failure,” “I’m too broken”) and are presently (or within 6 hours) having a very different relational experience regarding that original situation, the present relational experience will begin to replace those subjective feelings of shame with new, relational truths (“You are my beloved child, with you I am well pleased”). This will slowly delete the neural pathway at the synaptic level. These new, different relational experiences are referred to as Corrective Relational Experiences, a concept discovered by Sandor Ferenczi in the 1930s and later developed by various theorists, including Alexander and French (1946), Castonguay and Hill (2012), Ecker et al. (2024), and Fosha (2021). Corrective Relational Experiences best leverage Memory Reconsolidation through a three-step process (click here for more on this).

For example, my father would withdraw his love when I was disobedient or when I was not performing at my highest potential. I could feel the shame of this every time I was imperfect or willfully sinned. Fortunately, during my college years and later in therapy and a process group, I had close friends who drew closer to me, did not lose respect for me, enjoyed my company, and desired to continue growing closer to me, even when I was imperfect or made mistakes. These new Corrective Relational Experiences began to replace the old ones that were deeply ingrained. Slowly, my devastating shame was being deleted, and I could feel lovable even when I messed up.

Jesus used Corrective Relational Experiences in many interactions, which is why he was so effective, such as the Woman at the Well, Peter’s denial, the Parable of the Prodigal Son, and Zacchaeus, to name a few.

Here is where it gets exciting!

It goes without saying that we all experience some degree of shame, whether we recognize it or not. John spoke to this when he wrote: “There is no fear [shame] in love. But perfect love [drawing close to someone, loving them with ‘bad’ things in them] drives out fear [shame], because fear [shame]has to do [develops] with punishment [judgment, withdrawal of relationship]. The one who fears is not made perfect in love” (I John 4:18).

Shame develops when we mess up and people (especially in our family of origin or significant early relationships like teachers, sport coaches, churches) withdraw closeness and judge us. However, as John points out, and as we saw with Jesus and the Woman at the Well and the Parable of the Prodigal Son, shame decreases when people draw close and love those “bad, ugly parts.” This demonstrates God’s solution for shame.

First, the other side of grace encourages us to take from Jesus’ death and resurrection that we are lovable with “bad, ugly parts.” Click here for how Brennan Manning puts this – The one question you will be asked on judgment day.

Secondly, find a safe relationship where you experience Corrective Relational Experiences in the areas of shame.

This powerful combination of feeling the other side of grace from God and a human relationship is how shame is defeated, leaving us feeling incredibly free, whole, and loved. This is what Paul means by the “renewing of our minds” (Romans 12:2) to become a “new creation” (2 Corinthians 5:21) as part of God’s covenant family, the Church. This is neurological grace. Grace is not just a theological concept; it is a neurological mechanism for healing.

Our Churches would never be the same, nor would the World!

As Christians, we often love others based on performance – the other person doing the right thing to the best of their ability. Subtly yet powerfully, it creates or reinforces shame in others. Usually, this evolves out of our own shame. John spoke to this in 1 John 4:18. The one who fears [has shame] is not made perfect in love. In other words, you can only love others inversely to the level of shame you have in yourself. The higher the shame, the lower the love. The lower the shame, the more “unconditional love” – drawing close to others with their “ugly, bad parts”).

Following the great commandments, we experience the healing of our shame (as we encounter God’s and others’ unconditional love), and we provide healing to others. Can you imagine how people would flock to our churches if they experienced this kind of healing love through Corrective Relational Experiences? What if we had more time on Sunday morning to experience Corrective Relational Experiences with each other and in a small group? This is what makes the gospel so compelling! We invite people into a family where they are loved “good, bad, and ugly”— unlike anything the world can offer. And discipleship is not about collecting more biblical facts or a grim march toward sinless perfection; it’s relational, where we learn how to love others in the same way.

All of this is best illustrated by Jesus’ interaction with the Woman with the bleeding issue. Imagine this is how Jesus wants us to experience salvation and forgiveness. You can be loved with “unclean parts” like this woman with chronic bleeding.

About the author

Begin each day in the Word

New reflections and articles in your inbox. Unsubscribe anytime.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

This season

Abide

A season in John 15: what it means to remain in Christ, one morning at a time.

6 parts so far

All series