It is common knowledge that as we enter the holidays, we will be spending time with people we ordinarily avoid like a bad mechanic or a painful dentist. These are the obnoxious relations seated across the table from us.
As someone once quipped, the holidays bring families together, reminding us why God wisely scattered them across the country in the first place.
But that raises a serious question: Can we love someone when we really don’t like them?
Face it, sometimes the problem is entirely ours. We might complain to a friend, “Look, I know this is on me. But when she goes on about her weight loss at dinner and passes on my candied sweet potatoes…” Or, “When he tells that fishing story for the seventh time, it’s just unbearable!”
Sometimes our objections aren’t merely matters of personality. There are occasions when a family member or friend has really done something terribly wrong.
We all know the stories. The brother who borrowed money and never paid it back. The friend who broke a confidence. The nephew who only calls when he needs something. The sister who hasn’t spoken to Mom in three years over something no one can quite remember.
These hurts never make the newspaper, but they cut deep. And the person who causes them is often wounding his own soul as much as anyone else’s. As Proverbs reminds us, “A man who is kind benefits himself, but a cruel man hurts himself” (Proverbs 11:17).
Can we love someone when we disapprove of their choices? Is it possible to hate the sin and love the sinner?
I’d like to share the stories of two families.
Ben
Before I retired from full-time ministry, I served as pastor of a vibrant church in Florida. A man who had retired from South Carolina joined our congregation. Call him Ben.
Ben had done quite well as a businessman and was looking forward to doing everything he had put on the back burner. Our community had golf courses, swimming pools, and clubs for everything from pottery to salsa. Ben tackled all kinds of things. He even began reading Moby Dick. I told him, “Go at it,” and thought, “Better him than me.” And I was a Lit major.
Ben came by the office regularly, and as the staff got to know him, we learned that his son, Gene, was a professional athlete. Ben was justifiably proud. Naturally, he kept up with his son’s weekend exploits, and soon the office did too. Following Gene’s scores became one more duty for my administrative assistant.
Amid all this, I was happy to see Ben reconnect with our Lord. He was faithful in attendance and joined our midweek Bible study.
As sometimes happens, soon after his retirement Ben’s health took a turn for the worse. He had lived with diabetes since childhood. I knew that territory. My sister, Patti, had also been a juvenile diabetic, and hers was a fragile case. We lost her at thirty-nine, leaving behind her husband and two young daughters.
Ben had been more fortunate. For decades he had maintained a healthy lifestyle and managed the disease remarkably well. But diabetes can quietly take its toll, even when it appears to be under control.
Ben knew he had been having some kidney problems. Even so, when his doctor told him his kidneys were failing, the news came as a shock. He would need a transplant.
Here is where it got interesting. His son, Gene, appeared to be a promising potential donor. Their initial compatibility looked encouraging.
But Gene said, “No.”
As a professional athlete, he would not take the risk. Giving up a kidney would take him off the field for an uncertain period of time. It could shorten his career.
To be fair, organ donation is major surgery, with real risks.
As you can imagine, the church staff and Ben’s friends had their opinions about all of this. Not too many defended the young man’s decision. More than a few would have tripped Gene if he had walked into the Bonefish Grill.
But there was a wonderful lesson in this story.
It came from Ben.
He bore no ill will toward his son. He did not want to take his son’s lifelong dream away. He accepted his son’s decision, whatever it might cost him.
Ben passed away a few years later. He never blamed his son, not once. He was proud of him to the end.
The rest of us? Not so gracious. The office’s weekly score checks came to a quiet halt. We were no longer fans.
It’s ironic. The man with every reason to be bitter wasn’t. Those of us with no skin in the game were.
I knew Ben, but I never really knew Gene. Perhaps there were things about his decision I didn’t understand. What I do know is that Ben loved his son without resentment. And that was a lesson I needed.
Ben knew something we didn’t. Love doesn’t keep score.
He would be mortified to see this in print, and I can hear him telling me to leave it out. But this is what love looks like. My admiration for him continues to this day.
Tim and Mack
That brings me to my second story, from the lives of lifelong friends.
My wife, Tish, and I have dear friends whom I’ll call Marsha and Larry. They have three grown children, two sons and a daughter. Like most parents, they have taken great pleasure in watching their children build their own lives and families.
Their second son, Tim, is a good, personable, all-around guy, and he had been happily married.
Don’t pass over that word “had.”
Over the last two years, Tim had been experiencing dizziness and considerable fatigue. Thank you, Lord, he finally went in for blood work.
The results were a shock. Doctors discovered he had leukemia, and not just any leukemia, but acute myeloid leukemia (AML), an aggressive disease that can progress rapidly. Without effective treatment, it can become life-threatening very quickly.
There is hope in this dark scenario. A bone marrow transplant can sometimes offer not simply more years of life but the possibility of a cure. The question, as with a kidney transplant, is who might be a compatible donor.
Here is where this story takes a turn.
Tim is a lovable guy, but he made choices that cost him his marriage and broke faith with the people who loved him most. This was not a personality clash or a family squabble. It was a serious moral failure, and his family had every reason to be angry.
His brother and sister cut off communication. His sister still wants nothing to do with him. If a dog bit him, they would pet the dog and say, “Good boy.” Trust me on that.
His parents are outraged by his behavior, but they love him and, as you would expect, want him to live.
And, as you might suspect, Tim’s older brother, Mack, turned out to be a full match. I was surprised to learn that this was not a given. Full biological siblings have only about a one-in-four chance of being a complete tissue match.
The fact that Mack matched Tim is what we call a “God-thing.”
But would he do it?
The ancient Greeks had several words for love. We find some of them, or variations of them, expressed in the New Testament. Each describes a different kind of love we experience in our relationships with friends, family, and those closest to us.
C. S. Lewis famously explored four of these in his book The Four Loves, published in 1960. Two are especially common in families.
One such word is storge. It is the natural affection that grows out of familiarity and belonging. You don’t need to have much in common with someone to feel it. Think of a teenage boy and an old, scruffy, smelly dog that chews the furniture. The boy grew up with that dog, and when it’s time for that final trip to the vet, he’s the one who carries him in.
Paul captures something of this affection in Romans 12:10: “Love one another with brotherly affection. Outdo one another in showing honor.” One of the Greek words in this verse, philostorgoi, combines the ideas of friendship and family affection. Paul is encouraging Christians to show one another the kind of tenderness and affection we ordinarily associate with family.
Another word for love is philia. It is the love of friendship, built on shared interests and commitments. We hear it in the name Philadelphia, the City of Brotherly Love. Occasionally, Eagles fans need to be reminded to live up to their name.
Before their estrangement, Tim and Mack shared both. They were brothers. That was storge. They were hockey enthusiasts who genuinely enjoyed each other’s company. That was philia.
Then Tim deeply wounded the family. We cannot know what remained of Mack’s natural affection, and it is entirely plausible that their friendship was extinguished.
And yet, when push came to shove, Mack agreed to donate his bone marrow.
It was no small thing to ask of him, and no small thing to give. We cannot know what Mack felt when he arrived at the hospital that day. Perhaps some old brotherly affection stirred. Perhaps he was still angry. What we do know is that his willingness to help did not depend on whether he still enjoyed his brother’s company. Love was still there.
This is a third kind of love: agape. It is self-giving, sacrificial love that seeks another person’s good even when that person has done nothing to deserve it. Mack offered agape to his brother. Did Tim deserve it? In human eyes, no.
The Older Brother
Mack’s decision reminds me of another older brother who faced the same choice.
If you know the parable of the Prodigal Son, you know the younger son’s behavior was despicable. He left home and went off to the big, bad city. There, the kid blew his inheritance on wild living and hit rock bottom. Then, as Jesus put it, he came to his senses. He dragged himself home, rehearsing a little speech to give to his father: “I am no longer worthy to be called your son. Treat me as one of your hired servants” (Luke 15:19).
But his father would have none of it. He had not lost a servant; he had lost a son. And now his son was home. The father welcomed him without probation, threw a welcome-home dinner, and offered the same agape God offers you and me.
His older brother wanted no part of it.
He was beside himself that this brat would get off so easily. He had been putting in the extra hours while his brother was squandering the family fortune. Why reward him? And had he heard his little brother offering to return as a hired servant, I imagine he would have thought that was a splendid idea. He’d have the kid polishing his shoes by morning!
But didn’t he have a point? He had stayed home, worked hard, and done what was expected. And now there was a party? At least give the kid a month to prove he’s really changed his ways!
He had no intention of spreading a little agape on that brat. Jesus leaves him standing outside the celebration, and we never learn whether he went in. Could a few fatted-calf sandwiches have softened his heart? I wonder.
Mack stepped through the door.
“I Have Called You Friends”
The story of Tim and Mack continues. I pray that Tim, like the prodigal, will come to his senses.
His story reminds us that even when we “hate the sin,” we need to examine our own hearts. Can we still recall our storge for a brother or sister, a friend or relative? Can we remember the days before they were scruffy and living in the far country? Do we remember the philia, the friendship we once shared?
Perhaps the most wonderful thing about agape is that it can survive when affection has worn thin and friendship has been wounded.
Look at where these stories lead. Ben kept loving his son through disappointment. Mack gave something of himself to a brother who had hurt the whole family. The father ran to welcome a son who had squandered everything.
And Christ did more than all of them: “God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us” (Romans 5:8).
Notice what Jesus offers on the other side of that sacrifice. The prodigal hoped, at best, to come home as a hired servant. His father welcomed him as a son. Jesus goes further still: “Greater love has no one than this, that someone lay down his life for his friends” (John 15:13).
And then: “No longer do I call you servants … but I have called you friends” (John 15:15).
Agape, the love that gives itself away, can open the door to philia, the love of friends.
That is how God loves us.
So when you sit down at the holiday table this year, across from the relative who tries your patience, or the one whose choices have broken your heart, the storge may feel thin and the philia may have run dry.
You may not like them. You may not approve. But you can still choose their good. And who knows? By God’s grace, it may become the doorway to friendship again.
As C. S. Lewis wrote in Mere Christianity, “Do not waste time bothering whether you ‘love’ your neighbour; act as if you did. As soon as we do this we find one of the great secrets. When you are behaving as if you loved someone, you will presently come to love him.”
When our own well of affection runs dry, we don’t have to manufacture it. We simply lean on God’s strength, remembering Peter’s words: “Above all, keep loving one another earnestly, since love covers a multitude of sins” (1 Peter 4:8).
That is how we love.
God bless you. Now, would you mind passing the cranberry sauce?

