There is a vineyard on the hill behind the church I served, and for most of the thirty-one years I preached in that building I never once walked through it. I drove past it every Sunday. I admired it in October, when the leaves turn the color of old brass and the tour buses come up from the city. But I did not know the first thing about grapes until I retired and Ray Lindqvist asked if I wanted to make myself useful.
Ray has farmed those rows on the west side of Seneca Lake since he was a boy. His father planted some of the vines. One gray morning last March he handed me a pair of shears, walked me to the end of a row and showed me what pruning really means.
Cut back to almost nothing
I had imagined a little trimming, the way you tidy a hedge. Instead Ray took a vine that had sprawled all over its wire the summer before and cut away nearly all of it. When he was done there was a trunk, two short canes and a pile of brown wood at our feet that was easily bigger than what was left standing.
“Looks cruel,” he said, reading my face. “But if I leave all that on, she’ll put out a hundred little bunches and none of them worth picking. The vine only has so much in her. I’m telling her where to put it.”
I thought about that for the rest of the morning, and I have thought about it most mornings since.
I am the true vine, and my Father is the farmer. Every branch in me that doesn’t bear fruit, he takes away. Every branch that bears fruit, he prunes, that it may bear more fruit.
John 15:1–2 (WEB)
The branch has one job
What struck me, standing there in the cold with mud on my boots, was how little the branch has to do with any of it. The farmer decides where to cut. The root draws up the water. The sun does what the sun does. The branch has exactly one task, and it is not to try harder. It is to stay attached.
Remain in me, and I in you. As the branch can’t bear fruit by itself, unless it remains in the vine, so neither can you, unless you remain in me. I am the vine. You are the branches. He who remains in me, and I in him, the same bears much fruit, for apart from me you can do nothing.
John 15:4–5 (WEB)
The King James Bible I grew up with says abide: “Abide in me, and I in you.” I used to preach that word as a summons to effort, one more discipline to add to the list somewhere between tithing and Wednesday night supper. I am a little embarrassed by some of those sermons now. A branch does not abide by concentrating. It abides by not leaving.
For a pastor, and I suspect for most of us, that is harder than it sounds. I spent years producing things: sermons, budgets, a new roof for the fellowship hall. Some of it was good fruit, I hope. But a good deal of it grew out of my own nervous energy rather than time spent with the Lord: a hundred little bunches, none of them worth picking.

When the shears come
The part of John 15 we would rather skip is the pruning. Every branch that bears fruit, Jesus says, the Father prunes. Not the dead ones. The fruitful ones. That has been true in my life more often than I would like. The losses that cut deepest were not punishments. They were the Farmer deciding where the life of the vine should go.
I do not say that lightly, and I would not say it at all to someone in the first raw week of grief. But I have lived long enough to see that the years when I was cut back hardest were followed by some of the sweetest fruit. June and I lost our first child before he was born. We do not fully understand it even now. Yet the tenderness that grew in us afterward has been, I think, the best thing either of us has had to give.
Ray says you can pick out a well-pruned vine in July from across the road. It is not the biggest plant in the row. It is the one with the fruit.
A small practice for this week
If you want to sit with this passage, here is what I have been doing. It takes about ten minutes, usually with my coffee before June is up.
- Read John 15:1–11 slowly, out loud if you can. Notice how many times the word remain comes up.
- Ask the Lord one honest question: where am I straining to produce something you never asked me to grow?
- Sit quietly for a few minutes. You do not need to fix anything. Practice staying.
- Close by praying verse 9 back to him: “Even as the Father has loved me, I also have loved you. Remain in my love.”
This week the pickers are in Ray’s rows, and the vines I watched him cut back to bare sticks in March are hanging heavy with fruit. I am an old branch, and I have been slow to learn it, but I am learning that my job is to stay put and let the Farmer do his work.

