When I was twenty-three, a retired machinist named Frank asked me to breakfast. I’d been attending our church for about six months, mostly sitting in the back row and slipping out before the last song. Frank had noticed. Over pancakes at a diner on Cleveland Avenue, he asked how I was really doing. Then he asked if I’d like to meet again the next week.
We met most Tuesdays for four years. Frank never called it mentoring. He just opened his Bible, asked good questions, prayed for me by name and let me watch how an older man followed Jesus through ordinary life, including a hard retirement and his wife’s long illness. I’m a pastor today partly because Frank bought me breakfast.
Paul described this kind of passing-on to Timothy:
The things which you have heard from me among many witnesses, commit the same things to faithful men who will be able to teach others also.
2 Timothy 2:2 (WEB)
Not everyone gets a Frank who comes looking for them. Most of us have to do the looking, and the asking. Here’s how.
Know what you’re looking for
A mentor isn’t a therapist, a life coach or a celebrity pastor. You’re looking for an ordinary Christian a season or two ahead of you, someone whose faith you’ve seen hold up under pressure. Look for:
- Someone who loves Jesus in a way you can see, not just hear about.
- Someone who is honest about their own struggles.
- Someone in a stage of life you’re heading toward: a parent of teenagers if you have toddlers, a retiree if you’re nearing the end of your career.
- For most people, someone of the same sex, which keeps things simple and wise.
Look in ordinary places
The best mentors are rarely on a stage. Look at the usher who knows everyone’s name, the woman who has taught third-grade Sunday school for twenty years, the couple who always stay to stack chairs. Ask your pastor, too. Pastors usually know who has the gift of walking with people.
Make a small, specific ask
“Will you be my mentor?” can feel like an enormous request, to both of you. Make it smaller and clearer. Something like this:
I’ve noticed how you pray for people in our group, and I’d like to learn from you. Would you be willing to meet for coffee once a month for the next six months? I’d love to read a short book of the Bible together.
A time frame makes it easier to say yes, and easy to stop or continue when it ends. If the answer is no, thank them sincerely. It’s usually about their season, not about you.
What to do when you meet
- Read Scripture together. Choose a short book, like Philippians, James or 1 Peter, and read a chapter before each meeting.
- Bring one real question: about work, marriage, doubt, money, whatever is pressing on you.
- Pray for each other before you leave, and write down what you prayed.
- Follow through. If your mentor suggests something, try it and report back. Nothing encourages a mentor like seeing a suggestion taken seriously.
Then, one day, pass it on
The point of 2 Timothy 2:2 is that it doesn’t stop with you. Frank invested in me so that I would invest in others. These days I meet with three young men from our youth ministry, usually at the same kind of diner, usually over pancakes. I’m still learning. But I’ve noticed I ask a lot of Frank’s questions.
Iron sharpens iron; so a man sharpens his friend’s countenance.
Proverbs 27:17 (WEB)
Whose faith would you like to learn from? Pray about it this week. Then buy them a cup of coffee, and ask.

