Letters to a Young Believer: a gentle book for honest doubts

Eleanor Vance Whitlock’s letters to her goddaughter take doubt seriously without making a hero of it. I’ve given away six copies this year.

Letters to a Young Believer: a gentle book for honest doubts

We may earn a small commission from links on this page. It never costs you more. Read our disclosure policy

Most of my job happens in coffee shops. A student texts, “Can we talk?” and by the time we’ve found a table near the window, the real question is out: “What if I don’t actually believe this anymore?”

For a long time I didn’t have a book to hand them afterwards. The apologetics books I loved in college felt like being argued at, and most devotional books assumed a confidence the student didn’t have. Then a friend gave me Letters to a Young Believer, by Eleanor Vance Whitlock, and I’ve been giving it away ever since.

What the book is

It’s a collection of twenty-two letters Whitlock wrote to her goddaughter, Clare, over Clare’s first two years of faith. Clare started following Jesus at university and then, in her second year, hit a wall: her prayers felt like talking to the ceiling, a friend’s sudden death made no sense, and the answers she heard at church sounded thin. Whitlock, a retired schoolteacher, writes back slowly and patiently about doubt, prayer, the Psalms, church, and what she calls “walking with God when you can’t see the road.” Clare’s own letters aren’t included; we hear her only through the replies, which somehow makes it easier to put yourself in her place.

Advertisement

Songs of Hope 4U YouTube Channel

Immediately the father of the child cried out with tears, “I believe. Help my unbelief!”

Mark 9:24 (WEB)

What it gets right about doubt

Whitlock takes doubt seriously without making a hero of it. She never tells Clare her questions are silly, and she never tells her that doubt is the sign of a deeper faith, either. She treats it more like weather: real, sometimes frightening, and not the last word. In one of my favorite letters she writes:

You are not required to feel certain. You are only asked to keep walking, and to tell God the truth on the way.

Eleanor Vance Whitlock, Letters to a Young Believer

She’s also wise about prayer. Several letters are about what to do when prayer feels dead, and her advice is wonderfully practical. Pray the Psalms, because they already say what you can’t. Pray with other people, because their faith can carry yours for a while. And keep showing up, because “the door you are knocking on is not locked, only heavy.”

Where it falls short

The letters are written in a slightly old-fashioned voice, and a few students have told me the first chapter felt slow. I tell them to skip to the fourth letter and come back later. I also wish Whitlock had said more about doubt that grows out of being hurt by a church, which is the story behind a lot of the questions I hear. She touches on it but doesn’t stay long.

How I use it

  • I give it to students who are in the middle of a hard season, not the ones looking for a debate.
  • We read one letter a week and talk about it over coffee. Most letters take ten minutes to read.
  • I ask one question each time: “Which line did you underline, and why?”
Cover of Letters to a Young Believer

Letters to a Young Believer

by Eleanor Vance Whitlock

Twenty-two patient letters on doubt, prayer and walking with God, written to a goddaughter in her first hard years of faith. For students, new believers and the people who walk with them.

We may earn a small commission from links on this page. It never costs you more.

If you’re a pastor, a parent or a friend of someone who is quietly afraid they’re losing their faith, read it yourself first. Then give it away. In my experience it comes back with a lot of underlining.

About the author

Begin each day in the Word

New reflections and articles in your inbox. Unsubscribe anytime.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Subscribe to Bright Morning Star image

Free Email Newsletter

Free subscriber email newsletter links to our newest articles, Bible Studies, devotionals and videos.
Learn about us: Our Story ›

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Topics

Latest articles